Reviewed April 15th, 2002 by David Nusair
She Creature takes an agreeable enough premise that would suit a 30-minute short just fine, and stretches it out to a nearly unbearable hour and a half.
Rufus Sewell and Carla Gugino star as a pair of carnies – he’s the head of a large freak show while she plays a singing mermaid – who make the discovery of a lifetime. As they’re getting set to leave yet another town, they notice an old man still waiting by the mermaid section. After offering to drive him home, the old man offers to show them something amazing. They’re skeptical, but they humor the guy. Turns out he’s got a real live mermaid trapped in a tank within one of the many rooms of his house. Sewell nods appreciatively, but we can see he’s got plans for that abomination. He returns later with a crew, and proceeds to steal the half woman/half fish. The immediately board a boat bound for America, where Sewell believes he’ll be the toast of the town with his discovery. Unfortunately, the mermaid has other plans…
The idea behind She Creature is interesting enough – a killer mermaid massacres an entire crew – but it’s just not enough to fill an entire movie. The first hour and fifteen minutes limp by, and nothing much happens. We discover that the mermaid is able to communicate with anyone she wants via a psychic link, so Gugino finds herself on the receiving end of her telepathic transmissions. This leads to sequence after sequence of Gugino hanging around the room where the mermaid is kept, either chatting casually with her or imploring her not to kill anymore people. Let’s face it, with a title like She Creature (and backed by a production company entitled “Creature Features”) all we really want out of this movie is a bad-ass mermaid killin’ lots of folks. But we don’t get that until the final 15 minutes.
And then, when the psycho mermaid finally does begin offing hapless crew members, we don’t even get to see most of it! Sewell and a few other survivors stumble into what I can only assume was the mess hall, notice about a dozen dead men, and comment “why, she’s murdered the entire crew!” Lame. The ending’s not bad, I suppose, but it leaves the door unabashedly open for a sequel.
She Creature should have been cheesy and fun. Instead, it’s just cheesy.
Audio: This 5 channel DD soundtrack is actually quite impressive. Since the large majority of the flick takes place on a boat, you’d expect a lot of ambient sounds like thunder crashing and waves billowing against the ship. And you get it. At certain moments, it really does sound like you’re aboard that boat of death. However, the sound does seem a little too low during quieter moments, but raising the volume seems to fix that well enough.
Video: This anamorphically enhanced 1.85:1 transfer is effective, though not exactly eye candy. Dark scenes, of which there are many, are rendered effectively enough, with only modest amounts of grain popping up.
Extras: The primary extra here is a commentary track featuring legendary make-up guru Stan Winston, along with the head of special effects for She Creature, Shane ???. This is a mostly agreeable track, with few gaps but given that these men have a very specific focus, it’s not difficult to imagine that the majority of the track deals with make-up and special effects. Still, Winston obviously has a lot of passion and the two do point out a lot of interesting tidbits, so it’s hard to complain. Also included are a 2 and a half minute featurette (utterly useless), a photo gallery, some filmographies, and a trailer (along with trailers for other Creature Features movies, Dracula, Frankenstein, and a few other similarly horrific movies).
Conclusion: She Creature had potential to be an enjoyable little horror flick, but ends up nothing more than a curious oddity best left on the video store shelf.
Please help support our site by buying this DVD title
through this link. Thank you
Story / Content